Enforcing Chinese Awards Abroad

By Zhang Shichao

Winning an arbitration matters only if the award can be enforced where the losing party has assets. For Chinese arbitration institutions seeking international users, enforcement abroad is therefore a practical test of credibility. The governing framework is largely familiar: awards rendered in Mainland China generally travel under the same New York Convention that governs awards from other major arbitral jurisdictions.

That does not mean enforcement is automatic. Foreign courts still examine the limited defenses permitted by the Convention, especially notice, opportunity to be heard, jurisdiction, and public policy. The experience of Chinese awards abroad suggests a useful distinction: the award’s Chinese origin ordinarily is not the central issue; the quality of the arbitral process often is.

A Familiar Enforcement Framework

China acceded to the New York Convention in 1986 subject to reciprocity and commercial reservations. The Convention now provides the principal route for enforcing Chinese awards in most major trading jurisdictions. Article V permits refusal on limited grounds, including an invalid arbitration agreement, inadequate notice or inability to present a case, excess of authority, certain procedural defects, and public policy.

Chinese law also now makes the outward path clearer. Article 297 of the Civil Procedure Law and Article 85 of the 2025 Arbitration Law expressly contemplate direct application to a competent foreign court when the award debtor or its assets are abroad. A party does not first have to obtain a Chinese court order confirming the award. The 2025 law also gives the arbitral seat express statutory recognition, making the legal location of an award easier to identify for cross-border purposes.

Hong Kong and Macao operate under separate interregional enforcement arrangements rather than the New York Convention. In Hong Kong, the supplemental arrangement permits parallel applications in the Mainland and Hong Kong, subject to limits that prevent recovery beyond the amount owed. The larger point is that Chinese awards move through more than one enforcement architecture, but each depends on confidence in the underlying arbitral process.

What the Enforcement Record Shows

There is no comprehensive global database of applications to enforce Mainland Chinese awards, so broad recognition-rate claims should be treated cautiously. Published decisions and institutional reports nevertheless provide a growing body of examples. In 2024, CIETAC reported 758 new foreign-related cases involving parties from ninety-three countries and regions. Its awards were enforced that year in jurisdictions including the United States, Canada, Australia, Saudi Arabia, South Africa, and Vietnam.

The pattern is not confined to China’s largest institutions. In 2022, a U.S. federal court in California recognized and enforced an award issued by the Xiamen Arbitration Commission, a regional institution. That example is important because it separates international enforceability from institutional brand recognition. A court applying the Convention asks whether the award satisfies the applicable legal standards, not whether the administering institution has the international profile of CIETAC or another leading center.

Hong Kong provides a particularly substantial body of practice. HKIAC statistics report that 100 awards were granted enforcement in Hong Kong in 2024, thirty-seven of them originating from Mainland institutions. At the same time, Hong Kong courts retain authority to refuse enforcement when serious procedural defects undermine the fairness of the arbitration.

Where Awards Remain Vulnerable

Two cases illustrate why procedural integrity matters more than the nationality of the award. In Ma v. Fang, a U.S. court enforced a Xiamen Arbitration Commission award against a respondent who had received adequate notice but refused enforcement against another respondent who had not. The same award therefore produced different results because the parties had not received the same procedural protection.

Hong Kong’s Song Lihua v. Lee Chee Hon makes a related point. The court refused to enforce a Mainland award after concluding that an arbitrator participating remotely had failed to give the hearing adequate attention. The court’s concern was not that the award came from Mainland China. It was that the manner in which the hearing was conducted failed to satisfy basic standards of procedural justice.

For parties, counsel, and tribunals, those decisions point toward familiar precautions: use a clear arbitration agreement; preserve reliable evidence of service and notice; give each party a meaningful opportunity to present its case; address conflicts and recusal requests carefully; and document significant procedural decisions. Enforcement planning also should begin before the award, including identifying likely asset locations, limitation periods, translation requirements, and possible set-aside proceedings at the seat.

Enforcement as a Measure of Legitimacy

For the broader ADR community, enforcement abroad offers an unusually concrete way to evaluate institutional legitimacy. Surveys of preferred seats measure user perceptions. Cross-border enforcement decisions show what courts do when an award reaches them. The emerging record does not support the proposition that Chinese awards move effortlessly through every jurisdiction, nor would that be true of awards from any seat. It does show that foreign courts regularly enforce Chinese awards under familiar international standards and that the recurring vulnerabilities are recognizable ones: notice, opportunity to be heard, arbitrator conduct, and other aspects of procedural fairness.

That distinction matters as Chinese institutions become more active internationally. Their long-term credibility will depend less on assertions that their awards are enforceable than on producing proceedings that give enforcing courts little reason to refuse them. In that sense, the international enforcement of Chinese awards is not a separate stage that begins after arbitration ends. It is one consequence of how the arbitration was designed and conducted from the beginning.

The next post turns from whether an award can move across borders to whether the data inside an arbitration can. Jie (Jeanne) Huang examines the intersection of arbitral confidentiality, data protection, and cross-border information flows.

About the author

Zhang Shichao is a lecturer at the School of Humanities and Social Science, University of Science and Technology Beijing, and a research assistant at the Research Center for Dispute Settlement, Tsinghua University Law School.

This post draws on Zhang Shichao, “International Recognition and Enforcement of Chinese Arbitral Awards,” in Richard Bales & Dan Xie, eds., The Cambridge Handbook of Arbitration in China (Cambridge University Press, forthcoming spring 2027). The submitted chapter is available on SSRN.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.